Sensors & Control Engineering

Control refers to the process of regulating or manipulating the behaviour of a system to achieve desired outcomes. In electro mechanisms, control plays a key role in managing and optimizing system performance. It aims at reducing the error of an actuator response compared to the input order.

At CTEC, the driver and the controller parts are always combined in the same single box or rack referred to as “The controller”. The controller is based on microprocessor hardware with implemented digital control laws to allow fast, accurate and reliable computations.

feedback scheme
Diagram of a feedback control scheme.

Integrated in the control loop, the position sensor is a key element in a control loop to get a response from the mechanism output.

Sensors

As a standard practice at CTEC, we use strain gauges on our piezoelectric mechanisms. Directly bonded to the piezoelectric ceramic, the strain gauge allows for an indirect measurement of the mechanism’s movement through the deformation of the ceramic. These sensors offer the advantage of being compact and easily integrable. However, they have a limitation when the desired dynamic performance approaches the resonance frequency of the mechanism. The mechanical amplification of the resonance introduces an error between the expansion of the ceramics and the actual movement of the mechanism.

Strain Gauge integrated in a piezo actuator
Strain Gauge integrated in a piezo actuator
improving dynamic accuracy of closed loop bandwidth of piezo mechanisms with advanced control laws and embedded eddy current position sensors
Custom Eddy Current Sensor integrated in a TT60SM mechanism

For demanding control requirements and magnetic mechanisms, CTEC utilizes Eddy Current Sensors (ECS sensors) to achieve a direct reading of the mechanism. This technology, combined with a more advanced control, allows us to precisely control our mechanisms even up to and beyond their resonance. However, this type of sensor requires more space and imposes additional integration constraints on the mechanism.

CTEC can customise its Eddy Current Sensor technology to suit your specific application: embedded linear or angular sensors, such as flat ECS on PCB placed below the mirror in FSM and DTT mechanisms  and micro switching sensing solutions for tangential and normal motion detection.

Control

Depending on the application and the aimed performances, control is customized for each specific development. The table below summarizes the error analysis needs for different applications:

Functions

Slow positioning

Fast positioning

Tracking

Rejection of vibration

Applications

Static

Dynamic

Dynamic

Dynamic

Analysed performances

Amplitude error

Combined error: Amplitude and phase error, jitter, settling time

Combined error: Amplitude and phase error, jitter, rising time

Jitter, rejection of disturbances

Examples

Slow payload motion or pointing, point ahead mechanism or positioner

Fast steering mirror, XY stage for micro-scanning, shutter

Fast steering mirror for line-of-sight stabilization or deblurring function

Fast steering mirror, proof mass damper

To reach the expected performances cited above, CTEC can design several types of control laws and implement them in its digital controllers. The fast mechanical response of CTEC mechanisms (thanks to their high mechanical resonant frequencies) requires very fast processing (few tens of kHz) which is the main difference with standard control of electric motor (few kHz).

Standard Control law based on PID & Notch filters cannot provide controller with the capability to react to external perturbations at resonance frequencies and above. An advanced control law based on full state feedback and model identification combined with correct sensors allows to damp these perturbation inputs at resonant frequencies of the system.

Preshaping could be associated with these feedback law to enhance overall performance.

 

numeric control
A curve showing comparison between standard PID + Notch with SG and advanced full state feedback controls with ECS.
Comparison between standard PID + Notch with SG and advanced full state feedback controls with ECS.

The dynamic of the system is directly improved: the cut off frequency is higher, and the system response time is shorter.

This figure shows the benefit of advanced control compared to standard PID.

Graphe showing a sawtooth response patern
Comparison between standard PID and advanced control law for a sawtooth signal
Control graph showing a rosette patern
Optimized control of a FSM for circular and scanning rose dynamic pattern

The dynamic response is highly improved resulting in more precise mechanism control, regardless of the signal shape.

Rapid prototyping could be used to demonstrate the performance of the control.

A schematic describing implantation of Hardware in the Loop
Implantation of HIL (Hardware In the Loop) coupled with associated simulations

This type of advanced control can be implemented as part of a specific development process to achieve the highest performance. More information about our expertise in this area is available in our advanced control brochure.

The objective of the control team is to improve mechanisms speed and precision. When necessary, a focus could be made on developing new control laws to align with client performance needs. This involves identifying electromechanical models and implementing these control laws on digital platforms to ensure optimal performance and accuracy (using tools like Simulink, Mathlab, Speedgoat).

optical test bench photo
Optical qualification test bench for FSM close loop setting against vibration disturbances